Skip to main content

Professional Practice Dissertation Pre-Proposal, Part 1 of 4

My dissertation proposal as a culture-based education (CBE) version of Chopped All-Stars

Please indulge my need for metaphors and analogies to make sense of my world. This is Part 1 of  4 blog posts to clarify my thinking on my proposed dissertation topic. 

How will this study work?


  • Gather strong chefs, leaders and innovators in their own right and challenge them to create synergistic culinary masterpieces in the CBE Project, a professional development program.
  • change chef to teacher; change culinary masterpieces to culture-based education-infused practices and curriculum) 


The parameters: 
  • time (Kamehameha Hawaiʻi 4-week course with deadlines for teachers' own action research and learning portfolio to follow)
  • key ingredients (CBE practices, moenahā framework, makawalu,  and the  National Writing Project program model)
  • the course (teachers' own content area and current curriculum)
The question:
  • How does this PD impact teaching?
    • How does this PD help teachers to transform their own curriculum and practices through a Hawaiian worldview?
    •  What impact does it make on their identity as a teacher in a Hawaiian school?
Why this? Why now?

At the state, national, and international levels, indigenous culture-based educational strategies suggest promise where other Western culture-based strategies have failed in reducing educational disparities between indigenous students and their peers and in promoting positive and successful outcomes among indigenous students (Kanaʻiaupuni, 2007). 

If I have seen further,  it is by standing on the shoulders of giants 







Comments

Titah Thoughts said…
Sounds like a yummy proposal with some strong guiding questions to drive the study.
July 10, 2012 at 7:35 AM
Cathy Ikeda said…
Thanks - I hope so. I'm still working out the details, but so many giants have already done substantial work. I'm just trying to use what I know to weave things together for teachers.
July 10, 2012 at 9:56 PM
BigSpazz said…
so why four weeks? seems a bit long for a professional development training.
July 11, 2012 at 7:51 AM
Cathy Ikeda said…
@BigSpazz,
Great question! Why 4 weeks? What I have found in running summer institutes (the framework I am using for this project) is that for transformative thinking and application to take place, we need at least 2 1/2 - 3 weeks, even for teachers that come in as leaders and effective educators. At the 3rd week, the pieces of research, curriculum and practices starts to click and the teachers are ready to demonstrate their learning within the context of their classrooms.

When we've tried to shorten this think time, this marination time for teachers, we don't see the depth of their learning and the kind of "sticky" change that can translate to change in their own classrooms.

So it honors the time needed for change to happen, and it asks for a whole body commitment and sacrifice from teachers - if they come, they really want to be here, and they're not just looking for one shot PD that gives them credit, but doesn't change their pedagogy.
July 11, 2012 at 12:24 PM
BigSpazz said…
Ahh, so then why not longer? say over the course of a semester, to allow time to gather evidence of implementation and change?
July 11, 2012 at 1:37 PM
Cathy Ikeda said…
@BigSpazz,
I like your practical lens - why not offer a course that meets once a week for one semester, for example? I think that's a good model for courses that are asking teachers to try out strategies or tools with their students and then come back to class the next week with student samples, feedback, etc. That would be like a technology class on web tools or iPad apps that can be used to encourage higher order thinking skills.

The reason this is in a 4-week, everyday format is that this course will be designed around more than just content. It's not just about reading and discussing articles on CBE and moenaha. It is an immersion process where the class and how the day is scheduled also becomes a model for the concepts being taught. Relationships are important. Community is important. The process is important.

A dissertation was published on what elements in an NWP summer institute creates the transformation that is seen in teachers irregardless of location and content area. What the researcher found was that there were 5 elements that created this transformation: applied knowledge, active involvement, reflection, leadership and attitude.

The participants need the time in the summer, away from the obligations of the classroom and the school to really apply their knowledge in the thoughtful planning of their school year. They need to be involved in each others' projects as a community of learners and build up their leadership in a safe community, with the freedom of summer to self-reflect. These things are not possible when teachers are trying to also teach and counsel and work with famiies, grade papers etc.

I am not asking teachers to try out a strategy. I'm asking them to transform the way they create a learning environment in their classroom and the way they teach. I'm also asking them to teach their curriculum through a different lens, so they need focused support and focused, sacred time for that kind of transformative planning to happen.

Here's the link to the dissertation if you're interested.
http://krex.k-state.edu/dspace/bitstream/2097/447/1/RogerCaswell2007.pdf

Mahalo for encouraging to make my assumptions transparent. It really helps me to clarify my own thinking. :)
Cathy
July 11, 2012 at 3:59 PM
Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Kino (an indigenous logic model): post 1 of 4

Passion I have. What I need is to practice my elevator speeches, those short informative program synopses that can be done in the time it takes to ride the elevator.  Of course it will take me 4 posts. Post 1: The honua: building on solid ground The Alana culture-based education course is graphically depicted by the above logic model. The honua (green box), the earth, represents the mo'ok ūauhau, the geneology of this program that informs and guides the building of this course. Dr. Shawn Kanaʻiaupuni and her team lay the foundation for culture-based education (CBE) modeling and immersion within the course. Dr. Walter Kahumoku and Keiki Kawaiʻaeʻa, in consultation with Dr. Bernice McCarthy (4Mat) bring to the geneology the work of moenahā, a curriculum planning concept based on the way kupuna taught. Makawalu, literally eight eyes, is a concept practiced by Kaʻimipono Kaiwi and her teachers at Kamehameha Kapālama to encourage multiple perspectives in the standards-b...
Post a Comment
Read more

Battle of the Sexes

Ok, it's not a battle, but after being married for 20 years, I realize that there are some things that fall into the "mom's job" category, and there are some things that are strictly dad's domain. Mom's job is to find things. For 20 years I have lived in a male dominant household. The fact that the majority of the toilet seats in my house remain in the down position is a testament of the power of the one and only alpha female. However, what I can't do is teach my children (and my husband) how to do what I call "mom looking" versus "man looking." I don't need to explain this for the moms. They know exactly what I'm talking about. The guys are slower to catch on. I'll type s-l-o-w-l-y. Here's a typical "man looking" conversation: "mom! (or Cat!), where's the ______ (insert anything from socks to the car)?" "It's in the _________ (insert my instructions like refrigerator, garage, o...
3 comments
Read more

5 things that teachers do when they are in all-day workshops

1. Listen attentively for 10 minutes Presenters: welcome to your worst teaching nightmare. Teachers learn how to be antsy from their students. If you have a lot of middle school teachers, expect them to act like middle schoolers, ADHD disorders and all. You have 10 minutes to hook us and we want to get up, move and be active every half hour. 2. Talk to our neighbor while the presenter is still talking This practice is a natural way for teachers to use each other as a sounding board for the connections they are making to their own teaching (or they're just gossiping). If you can't tell the difference between productive noise and idle gossip, you need to go back to the classroom and practice. 3. Text and read posts When speakers talk about another author, or another concept, we get on our smart phones and look up the links so we can expand our knowledge immediately. (Or we're blogging or catching up on our email). Don't be offended. Only kick us out if we don't realiz...
2 comments
Read more